Skip to content
10% Off Our Holiday Collection Products with Promo Code "Holidays"
10% Off Our Holiday Collection Products with Promo Code "Holidays"
Catering Supplies

Catering Supplies

Whether you're hosting friends or providing first-class catering service, Paper Supplies Plus has you covered with the right supplies to have everyone saying WOW!
  • Ice / Candy Scoop - Paper Supplies Plus
    Ice / Candy Scoop - Paper Supplies Plus
    $29.50

    Ice / Candy Scoop (48 Per Case) Avail. Black, Clear, and White

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 3314Description: Ice / Candy ScoopPacking: 48/caseTotal Pcs/Case: 48

    $29.50
  • Salad Scissor Tongs (48/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    Salad Scissor Tongs (48/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $59.50

    Salad Scissor Tongs (48/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 3304Description: Salad Scissor TongsPacking: 48/caseTotal Pcs/Case: 48

    $59.50
  • Silver Cake Cutter (40/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    Silver Cake Cutter (40/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $39.50

    Silver Cake Cutter (40/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    The perfect resource for your serving utensil needs. We've got your measure! Fork it over; dish it out; no stress, no fuss, we cut it out! Item # 7...

    View full details
    $39.50
  • 8.5" Silver Tongs (40/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    8.5" Silver Tongs (40/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $59.00

    8.5" Silver Tongs (40/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    The perfect resource for your serving utensil needs. We've got your measure! Fork it over; dish it out; no stress, no fuss, we cut it out! Item # 7...

    View full details
    $59.00
  • 10" Silver Serving Spoons (60/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    10" Silver Serving Spoons (60/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $44.50

    10" Silver Serving Spoons (60/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    The perfect resource for your serving utensil needs. We've got your measure! Fork it over; dish it out; no stress, no fuss, we cut it out! Item # 7...

    View full details
    $44.50
  • 10" Silver Serving Forks (60/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    10" Silver Serving Forks (60/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $49.50

    10" Silver Serving Forks (60/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    The perfect resource for your serving utensil needs. We've got your measure! Fork it over; dish it out; no stress, no fuss, we cut it out! Item # 7...

    View full details
    $49.50
  • 6" Cocktail Forks (Silver)-400/CS - Paper Supplies Plus
    6" Cocktail Forks (Silver)-400/CS - Paper Supplies Plus
    $42.00

    6" Cocktail Forks (Silver)-400/CS

    Fineline Settings

    Dish in with these mini disposable utensilsSo you can have your cake and eat it too! Item # 6510Description: 6" Cocktail ForksPacking: 20/pvc,20/ct...

    View full details
    $42.00
  • 6" Cocktail Forks (Clear)-400/CS - Paper Supplies Plus
    6" Cocktail Forks (Clear)-400/CS - Paper Supplies Plus
    $39.00

    6" Cocktail Forks (Clear)-400/CS

    Fineline Settings

    Dish in with these mini disposable utensilsSo you can have your cake and eat it too! Item # 6510Description: 6" Cocktail Forks,ClearPacking: 20/pvc...

    View full details
    $39.00
  • 1 GALLON ICE BUCKET, FROSTED (6 BUCKETS/CASE) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $69.50

    1 GALLON ICE BUCKET, FROSTED (6 BUCKETS/CASE)

    Fineline Settings

    Chill! We're pitching in! Item # 3403Description: 1 Gallon Ice Bucket, FrostedPacking: 6/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 6

    $69.50
  • 1 GALLON OVAL ICE BUCKET, CLEAR (6 BUCKETS/CASE) - Paper Supplies Plus
    1 GALLON OVAL ICE BUCKET, CLEAR (6 BUCKETS/CASE) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $69.50

    1 GALLON OVAL ICE BUCKET, CLEAR (6 BUCKETS/CASE)

    Fineline Settings

    Chill! We're pitching in! Item # 3404Description: 1 Gallon Oval Ice Bucket, ClearPacking: 6/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 6

    $69.50
  • 6 QT. ICE BUCKET, Polypropylene (24/Case) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $59.00

    6 QT. ICE BUCKET, Polypropylene (24/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Item # ICB2046Description: 6 QT. ICE BUCKET, PolypropylenePacking: 24/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 24Color: Clear

    $59.00
  • 7.5 Oz Mini Carafe (60/Case) - Paper Supplies Plus
    7.5 Oz Mini Carafe (60/Case) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $69.00

    7.5 Oz Mini Carafe (60/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 6417Description: 7.5 Oz Mini CarafePacking: 6/pvc,10/ctnTotal Pcs/Case: 60 More Info: 4.5" Tall x 2" Top x 2.35" Bottom

    $69.00
  • 20 oz. Carafe, w/Lid (12/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    20 oz. Carafe, w/Lid (12/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $42.50

    20 oz. Carafe, w/Lid (12/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 3420Description: 20 oz. Carafe, w/LidPacking: 12/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 12 Material: PETE/PP More Info: 8.75" Tall Carafe with PP Lid

    $42.50
  • 35 oz. Carafe, w/Lid (12/Case) - Paper Supplies Plus
    35 oz. Carafe, w/Lid (12/Case) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $79.00

    35 oz. Carafe, w/Lid (12/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 3405Description: 35 oz. Carafe, w/LidPacking: 12/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 12 Material: PETE/PPMore Info: 10.5" Tall Carafe with PP Lid

    $79.00
  • 50 oz. Pitcher (50/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $69.00

    50 oz. Pitcher (50/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Chill! We're pitching in! Item # 3401Description: 50 oz. PitcherPacking: 50/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 50

    $69.00
  • 60 oz. Heavy Duty Pitcher (12/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $39.00

    60 oz. Heavy Duty Pitcher (12/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 3402Description: 60 oz. Heavy Duty PitcherPacking: 12/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 12

    $39.00
  • 8" - 64 OZ. HALF GALLON PITCHER (12/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    8" - 64 OZ. HALF GALLON PITCHER (12/CS) - Paper Supplies Plus
    $49.00

    8" - 64 OZ. HALF GALLON PITCHER (12/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 550CLDescription: 8" - 64 OZ. HALF GALLON PITCHERPacking: 12/CaseTotal Pcs/Case: 12 Material: Polystyrene

    $49.00
  • 5" x 2.6" Tiny Tureens (240 Count)
    5" x 2.6" Tiny Tureens (240 Count)
    $97.50

    5" x 2.6" Tiny Tureens (240 Count)

    Fineline Settings

    Tantalize on so many levels!Times of gladness deserve trays of beauty that lead to tiers of joy! Item # 6303 Description: 5" x 2.6" Tiny Turee...

    View full details
    $97.50
  • 5" TINY TENSILS (ASIAN SPOON) -200/CS - Paper Supplies Plus
    5" TINY TENSILS (ASIAN SPOON) -200/CS - Paper Supplies Plus
    $32.00

    5" TINY TENSILS (ASIAN SPOON) -200/CS

    Fineline Settings

    Dish in with these mini disposable utensilsSo you can have your cake and eat it too! Item # 6505Description: 5" Tiny TensilsPacking: 10/bag,20/ctnT...

    View full details
    $32.00
  • Compostable Mini Angled Bowl (500 Per Case)
    $59.00

    Compostable Mini Angled Bowl (500 Per Case)

    Fineline Settings

    CATERING OPTIONS MADE FROM EARTH FRIENDLY BAGASSE100% COMPOSTABLE   Collection: ConservewareItem # 42MAB01Description: Mini Angled BowlPacking: 25/...

    View full details
    $59.00
  • 4" Mini Taster Spoon (500 Per Case)
    $59.00

    4" Mini Taster Spoon (500 Per Case)

    Fineline Settings

    CATERING OPTIONS MADE FROM EARTH FRIENDLY BAGASSE100% COMPOSTABLE   Collection: ConservewareItem # 42MTSTSDescription: 4" Mini Taster SpoonPacking:...

    View full details
    $59.00
  • 2.25" Mini Square Dish (500 Per Case)
    $64.50

    2.25" Mini Square Dish (500 Per Case)

    Fineline Settings

    CATERING OPTIONS MADE FROM EARTH FRIENDLY BAGASSE100% COMPOSTABLE   Collection: ConservewareCollection: ConservewareCategory: MiniwareItem # 42MSQR...

    View full details
    $64.50
  • 3.75" Mini Leaf Dish (500 Per Case)
    $69.00

    3.75" Mini Leaf Dish (500 Per Case)

    Fineline Settings

    CATERING OPTIONS MADE FROM EARTH FRIENDLY BAGASSE100% COMPOSTABLE   Item # 42MLFDescription: 3.75" Mini Leaf DishPacking: 25/BAG 20/CS-500 PCSTotal...

    View full details
    $69.00
  • Fineline Renaissance 1512- 12 oz. Bowl  (120/Case)
    Fineline Renaissance 1512- 12 oz. Bowl  (120/Case)
    $79.50

    Fineline Renaissance 1512- 12 oz. Bowl (120/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    When expectations are heightened, it’s time for a setting that’s enlightened. Let yourself be inspired by the cultured contours of this collection....

    View full details
    $79.50
  • Fineline Renaissance 1508- 7.5" Salad Plate  (120/Case)
    Fineline Renaissance 1508- 7.5" Salad Plate  (120/Case)
    $57.50

    Fineline Renaissance 1508- 7.5" Salad Plate (120/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    When expectations are heightened, it’s time for a setting that’s enlightened. Let yourself be inspired by the cultured contours of this collection....

    View full details
    $57.50
  • Fineline Renaissance 1510- 10" Dinner Plate  (120/Case)
    Fineline Renaissance 1510- 10" Dinner Plate  (120/Case)
    $89.50

    Fineline Renaissance 1510- 10" Dinner Plate (120/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    When expectations are heightened, it’s time for a setting that’s enlightened. Let yourself be inspired by the cultured contours of this collection....

    View full details
    $89.50
  • Fineline Renaissance 1506- 5.5" Dessert Plate  (120/Case)
    Fineline Renaissance 1506- 5.5" Dessert Plate  (120/Case)
    $44.50

    Fineline Renaissance 1506- 5.5" Dessert Plate (120/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    When expectations are heightened, it’s time for a setting that’s enlightened. Let yourself be inspired by the cultured contours of this collection....

    View full details
    $44.50
  • Classic 12" Round Tray (25/Case)
    Classic 12" Round Tray (25/Case)
    $29.00

    Classic 12" Round Tray (25/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Spark your inner culinary creativity with Innovative Caterware. Innovative designs utilizes high percentages of recycled content to make high perfo...

    View full details
    $29.00
  • Classic 14" Round Tray (25/Case)
    Classic 14" Round Tray (25/Case)
    $34.50

    Classic 14" Round Tray (25/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Spark your inner culinary creativity with Innovative Caterware. Innovative designs utilizes high percentages of recycled content to make high perfo...

    View full details
    $34.50
  • Classic 16" Round Tray (25/Case)
    Classic 16" Round Tray (25/Case)
    $45.00

    Classic 16" Round Tray (25/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Spark your inner culinary creativity with Innovative Caterware. Innovative designs utilizes high percentages of recycled content to make high perfo...

    View full details
    $45.00
  • Classic 18" Round Tray (25/Case)
    Classic 18" Round Tray (25/Case)
    $59.00

    Classic 18" Round Tray (25/Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Spark your inner culinary creativity with Innovative Caterware. Innovative designs utilizes high percentages of recycled content to make high perfo...

    View full details
    $59.00
  • 12" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)
    12" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)
    $45.00

    12" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Entertain royally with a majestic touch!Steady and Stacked for best impact. Item # 7210TF Description: 12" Round TrayPacking: 25/CaseTotal Pcs/Case...

    View full details
    $45.00
  • 16" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)
    16" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)
    $54.50

    16" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Entertain royally with a majestic touch!Steady and Stacked for best impact. Item # 7610TF Description: 16" Round TrayPacking: 25/CaseTotal Pcs/Case...

    View full details
    $54.50
  • 18" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)
    18" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)
    $59.00

    18" PET Thermoform Round Black Tray (25/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Entertain royally with a majestic touch!Steady and Stacked for best impact. Item # 7810TF Description: 18" Round TrayPacking: 25/CaseTotal Pcs/Case...

    View full details
    $59.00
  • 6 OZ. TWISTED CUP (600/CS)
    6 OZ. TWISTED CUP (600/CS)
    $179.50

    6 OZ. TWISTED CUP (600/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Serve up your next cocktail party!Treat yourself to every type of rim; indulge to the brim! Item # 6419Description: 6oz Twisted Cup Total Pcs/Case:...

    View full details
    $179.50
  • 2.25" x 3" Tiny Tumblers (Approx. 4 Ounces)  (200/CS)
    2.25" x 3" Tiny Tumblers (Approx. 4 Ounces)  (200/CS)
    $89.50

    2.25" x 3" Tiny Tumblers (Approx. 4 Ounces) (200/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Serve up your next cocktail party!Treat yourself to every type of rim; indulge to the brim! Item # 6404Description: 4 OZ. TINY TUMBLERS (2.25" x 3"...

    View full details
    $89.50
  • 4" Tiny Tasting Forks  (Packed-960/CS)
    4" Tiny Tasting Forks  (Packed-960/CS)
    $59.50

    4" Tiny Tasting Forks (Packed-960/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    Dish in with these mini disposable utensilsSo you can have your cake and eat it too! Item # 6500Description: 4" Cocktail ForksPacking: 48/pvc,20/ct...

    View full details
    $59.50
  • 12" - 6 COMPARTMENT TRAY, POLYPRO (50 Trays Per Case)
    12" - 6 COMPARTMENT TRAY, POLYPRO (50 Trays Per Case)
    $97.50

    12" - 6 COMPARTMENT TRAY, POLYPRO (50 Trays Per Case)

    Fineline Settings

    Spark your inner culinary creativity with Compartment Trays by Platter Pleasers. Inside you'll find a host of rigid round compartment cater trays t...

    View full details
    $97.50
  • 10" Gold Serving Forks (60/CS)
    10" Gold Serving Forks (60/CS)
    $49.50

    10" Gold Serving Forks (60/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    A sturdy, disposable plastic serving fork is the perfect way to serve a delicious culinary delight to your guests at your next party or event. With...

    View full details
    $49.50
  • 10" Gold Serving Spoons (60/CS)
    10" Gold Serving Spoons (60/CS)
    $49.50

    10" Gold Serving Spoons (60/CS)

    Fineline Settings

    These gold plastic serving spoons are of great value. This means you'll save money in the long run and never need to purchase fragile silverware ag...

    View full details
    $49.50
  • 96oz Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls- 24/CS (Black, White, & Clear)
    96oz Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls- 24/CS (Black, White, & Clear)
    $69.00

    96oz Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls- 24/CS (Black, White, & Clear)

    Fineline Settings

    Make an impression on your guests when you choose the 3 qt. Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls to serve them from. These bowls replace standar...

    View full details
    $69.00
  • 128oz Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls- 24/CS (White & Clear)
    128oz Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls- 24/CS (White & Clear)
    $89.00

    128oz Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls- 24/CS (White & Clear)

    Fineline Settings

    Make an impression on your guests when you choose the 3 qt. Square Disposable Plastic Serving Bowls to serve them from. These bowls replace standar...

    View full details
    $89.00
  • Gold Cake Cutter/Lifter (40 Per Case)
    $32.00

    Gold Cake Cutter/Lifter (40 Per Case)

    Fineline Settings

    These gold plastic serving spoons are of great value. This means you'll save money in the long run and never need to purchase fragile silverware ag...

    View full details
    $32.00
  • 2 oz. Punch Ladle (48 Pieces) Avail. Black, Clear, & White
    2 oz. Punch Ladle (48 Pieces) Avail. Black, Clear, & White
    $29.50

    2 oz. Punch Ladle (48 Pieces) Avail. Black, Clear, & White

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 3306Description: 2 oz. Punch LadlePacking: 48/CS Material: PSMore Info: Individually Wrapped and Barcoded

    $29.50
  • 5 oz. Punch Ladle (48 Pieces) Avail. Black, Clear, & White
    5 oz. Punch Ladle (48 Pieces) Avail. Black, Clear, & White
    $69.00

    5 oz. Punch Ladle (48 Pieces) Avail. Black, Clear, & White

    Fineline Settings

    Item # 3305Description: 5 oz. Punch LadlePacking: 48/CS Material: PSMore Info: Individually Wrapped and Barcoded

    $69.00
  • Bamboo 2 Piece Serving Set - L:10in -25 Sets
    Bamboo 2 Piece Serving Set - L:10in -25 Sets
    $105.00

    Bamboo 2 Piece Serving Set - L:10in -25 Sets

    Fineline Settings

    Bamboo 2 Piece Serving Set - L:10in - 50 Pcs Sets: Serving Fork & Spoon Case Pack: 25 Sets Per Case

    $105.00
  • Bamboo Serving Tongs - L:10in - 50 Pcs.
    Bamboo Serving Tongs - L:10in - 50 Pcs.
    $89.50

    Bamboo Serving Tongs - L:10in - 50 Pcs.

    Fineline Settings

    Bamboo Serving Tongs - L:10in - 50 Pcs. Our bamboo serving tong can be used for hot and cold food items. 100% biodegrable, our bamboo cutlery are a...

    View full details
    $89.50